Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Changing My Position: Review of an E-Reader

Recently, it was my good fortune to become the owner of an e-reader, specifically the Kindle Touch 3G.  Previously, I had pooh-poohed these devices, stating that bound paper was the only reading format for me. Who would want to spend any more time than necessary staring at a screen? Certainly, not I.  Still, I was thrilled to receive the Kindle because it finally occurred to me that 1) this device would augment my bound books--not replace them and 2) it is more book-like than computer-like.

The e-reader's chief advantage is convenience: I don't have to leave my house to find something new to read.  Let me repeat--I can remain horizontal, indeed, practically paralyzed, and access umpteen books. My hot little hand can hold an entire library.  Granted, ninety-nine percent of amazon.com books cost $$$ (as opposed to the free public library); however, I've found that there are some free Kindle books worth downloading:
  •  The Adventures of Tom Sawyer  (and many, many more classics!)
  • 5-Minute Recipes
  • The Book of Tea
  • Dishes & Beverages of the Old South
  • History of the Donner Party
  • How to be Sexy
  • A Little Bit of Everything for Dummies
  • The Woman's Bible
  • The Kama Sutra
Okay, I haven't downloaded the last title in the list, but if I want to, I can have it with a simple touch of the screen. (Well, maybe not so simple, but more on that in a moment.)  Even new releases at approximately $9.99 are a better deal than their hardback cousins.

So, I give e-readers top marks for convenience and value. But what about ease of use?  Erm, well, here's where the Kindle falters in comparison to good old paper.  The packaged device arrived with paltry written instructions because the User's Guide was already loaded onto the device. Makes sense, right?  So, I've accessed the electronic guide several times but have found it likewise paltry as an information source.  Typing "delete books" in the search field yields one or two sentences on archiving rather than deleting them. From what I can gather, on some Kindles, you can't actually delete anything. Downloads are archived in perpetuity. (Hence, my concern about the Kama. I need to be able to digest it and ditch it, don't I?)

Second, the touch mechanism to turn pages isn't as easy to execute as the old fashioned thumb to forefinger method.  Maybe sometimes I touch too hard or too softly because the Kindle will jump ahead more than one page or won't budge at all.  And, when I "dogear" pages on the Kindle (a feature I dearly love), sometimes the device thinks I want to do a search or change the font. I'm not sure how I could do anything differently in touching the top right hand corner of the screen. My move seems straightforward to me, but the e-reader often has other ideas.  Furthermore, if I close the cover after dogearing a page, sometimes the dear Kindle has lost my place entirely. (I think my adorable hot pink cover's touch is making it race ahead.)

Still, the e-reader's positives far outweigh the negatives. (Library in my purse!)  And I'm slowly adjusting to the subtleties of touch needed to navigate its narratives.  Perhaps, unlike bound analog material, the e-reader is just waiting for the reader to perfect her digits' digital sense.  After all, according to The Kama Sutra, practice should lead to the perfect touch. (Or so I've heard.)

10 comments:

  1. Elisabeth,
    I bet you can check out books from your public library on your Kindle. I have done it many times from the Spartanburg public library and surely Jacksonville is more advanced than we are! It is pretty cool because the book just disappears after the lending period so you don't even have to remember to return it. Margaret told me about your trip to Columbia and I have it on my calendar so hopefully I will be able to come down.
    Anne Louise

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anne Louise, so glad we might get to see you in March! Re books from library here, yes, we can do that. I haven't tried it yet, but it sounds ideal! Right now, b/t borrowed paper books and free Kindle ones, I have plenty to read. Now, I just need more time. :-P
    Elisabeth

    ReplyDelete
  3. I use my daughter's Kindle all the time (She is my instruction manual.) I love the instant access to books. And best of all, I can adjust the font size and forgo the granny glasses.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So true about the font adjusting! I find it's easier on the eyes too!

      Delete
  4. Elisabeth - I fell in love with my e-reader (the kindle app on the iPad) instant access, a whole library at my finger tips, and like you I had been skeptical...now it's difficult to put it down and get on with my day!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nan, I just love that I can browse all those titles and pick any. I download a lot of quirky stuff along with gold, but that's just how a real library is!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Actually you can ditch a book once you buy it from Amazon. You go to your Amazon account and delete it from your digital media there. Once you do you have to rebuy it if you want to reread it. So go ahead and read the Kama Sutra.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Aha! Well, this tidbit was not in the User's Manual. Thanks, guru! I've also bought some other trash on there I need to get rid of. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have the Kindle app on my Ipad and I just love it. Being an English Lit major, I was against making the switch from good old ink and paper, but I love having a library in my purse at all times! It really helps me deal with the frustration of having to wait for Doc H all the time!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for your comment! (And I do enjoy following you on twitter!) So agree with your switch and reasoning for same. I must admit also, that I feel more fashionable with a pink-sheathed electronic device in my hand rather than a book. Sacrilege, I know, since I was trained as a librarian. I'm sort of a sucker for style though.
      Elisabeth

      Delete